Velcro saline sensor headset

wjcroftwjcroft Mount Shasta, CA
edited March 2018 in Headware
Here is a link and a couple photos of the velcro based saline sensor system. Saline sensor systems have the advantage that they do not need paste or gel, hence application and cleanup is easier. The Emotiv EPOC is an example of a saline system that uses small saline soaked felt pads.

The article includes instructions on how you can build this yourself. Either with the gold cup sensors you received with OpenBCI, or with Silver / Silver Chloride sensor buttons. Also included is a list of manufacturers I am aware of, who make commercial saline systems that can be purchased.



View of the headset in 5 channel Open Focus alpha synchrony configuration (Fpz Cz Oz T3 T4).  Reference is using linked ears, Bias is at ~ Fz.

image


View with the headset in place. Cable bundle tacked at shirt collar. OpenBCI clipped to shirt (visible in article photo). LiPo battery in my pants pocket.

image

William

PS I have a couple other pages I'm composing on Brainbay neurofeedback designs. Will post those shortly.

Comments

  • Thanks for this William -- very helpful as always! 
  • Thanks for posting this.

    I take it your chamois-wrapped cup electrodes are also meant to be used with saline solution? And suitable as long as you don't care about very low frequencies?
  • wjcroftwjcroft Mount Shasta, CA
    Baobob, yes, I'm sorry if that wasnt clear.

    The page link above is intended to show that saline sensor electrodes can be constructed in a wide variety of ways. The basic principle is an EEG electrode (of any type), with a layer of saline soaked absorbent material (chamois, felt or thin sponge), between the skin and the electrode.

    The electrode material made of silver chloride is only a necessity if working with frequencies less than .1 hz. The page also has a 'commercial' headset page where it shows other metallic cup sensors employed in saline systems.

    William

  • Nice work.  I always love seeing different approaches to headgear.
  • I have used saline and sham-wow for quite a while with good success.  The setup is very much like that described above.  Electrodes have been tin cups.  I like electrodes that are solid metal rather than plated.  While the gold electrodes are vey good, even the slightest scratch in the surface can expose the base metal creating a battery effect that damages signal integrity.  I am experimenting with modestly elastic hood and loop strips, inspired by the gentle elastic used in CPAP head gear.

    George
  • wjcroftwjcroft Mount Shasta, CA
    edited January 2015
    George, cool.

    Is that the Velstretch you are using?

    https://www.google.com/search?q=velstretch

    I'll post a photo of this material. It actually is compatible with the Velcro One-Wrap. It is a stretchy 1 inch wide strap, that has a surface that hook material can mate with. So it mates with the hook side of the One-Wrap. On the very end of the Velstretch is about a 5 inch length of hook only material. This appears to be exactly the same as the hook side of the One-Wrap.

    The downside of the Velstretch is it is loopy on BOTH sides. When using the One-Wrap in the saline system, you place the soft loopy side next to the skin. And leave the hooks facing outward. So for example if you used the Velstretch as the circumferential "hat-band", it would only mate with One-Wrap straps that have the hook side facing INWARD. Sigh. Well, I think this form of stretchy strap that is compatible with One-Wrap still will have some uses. One way might be to just portions of it interspersed, rather than one continuous hat band of Velstretch.

    My guess is that with all the 3D printer guys out there, we'll see some interesting hybrids of printed electrode holders and the types of velcro.

    Post a photo or other info on your CPAP inspired headset.

    Cheers,

    William

  • William,

    I ordered the velcro straps from strap works.com  one inch wide black elastic $.20 per foot.

    I will upload a photo when the strap is complete and working,  I will attach hooks to the end of the elastic straps.  I think the elastic will be a bit more comfortable than cinching on a straight velcro strap.  
  • Rock on, William!
  • biomurphbiomurph Brooklyn, NY
    Very handsome!
  • I really like William's post. Good idea, and easy to set up. The only question I have is, if you're using the Velcro setup to place the electrodes in the correct positions, how do you define and mark the site positions on the 10/20 system?  Maybe I missed this somewhere along the line, but I'm not clear about this.

    Stan

  • wjcroftwjcroft Mount Shasta, CA
    edited December 2015
    Stan, hi.

    If you've used cup electrodes and paste for a little while, you get very familiar with the standard 10-20 site locations and how to 'eyeball' their placement. Cup electrodes are used by the majority of neurofeedback practitioners, so this is straightforward to learn.

    http://openbci.com/forum/index.php?p=/discussion/176/placing-electrode-sensors-on-the-scalp

    The landmarks are the "hat band" around the circumference of the head (which contains the Fp1 Fp2 T3 T4 O1 O2 sites). And the 'top' of the head, typically above the ears, halfway between the nasion and inion (Cz). The Frontal Fz line is halfway between Cz and Fpz. The Parietal Pz is halfway between Cz and Oz. Similar for locating X3, X4; halfway down.

    This same saline sensor idea can be used with other headgear such as the BraiNet or g.tec g.GAMMAcap. See the thread on caps,

    http://openbci.com/forum/index.php?p=/discussion/191/elastic-head-caps-electro-cap-g-gammacap-etc

    William

  • William
    I have considered the BrainNet system in the past. I know they are approved as single use. Do you know how robust they are. I would like to replace them frequently with multiple uses

    Thanks
    George
  • Thanks for the speedy response William.  Keep up the good work.
    Stan
  • wjcroftwjcroft Mount Shasta, CA
    George, hi. I've not used the BraiNet 'caps' myself, only seen photos. They certainly LOOK like they can be used many times. The other components of that system (such as their disposable electrodes) are indeed geared for single use. But I think if you are gentle with the elastic, a given cap should last probably many months before needing replacement. They are certainly relatively inexpensive,


    I use Fabri-Tac fabric glue with my saline pockets; it's one of the best fabric glues I've found. If any small tears or unglues happened with the BraiNet, they could likely be repaired with the Fabri-Tac.

    William



  • Thanks much

    George
  • wjcroft), 
    How are you securing the electrodes along the z (midline) strap (along the sagital plane) at locations where there's no intersecting transversal or coronal straps? I mean, e.g. Pz, Fz, etc?
    What I found out was that since the sagital strap isn't closed (like the transverse and the coronal ones) there's not enough downward pressure applied to the electrode and the connection is flaky.

    Thx,
    David
  • wjcroftwjcroft Mount Shasta, CA
    David, hi. I always use cross straps (left to right) in addition to the front to back midline strap. i put the 'hatband' on first, then the midline, then the cross strap(s). Be sure your hatband is modestly snug so that it can exert some downward force when the front to back and left to right straps are attached.

    Does that make sense?

    William

  • William, thx. How many cross straps layers do you use?

    I understand that "hatband" is transverse / horizontal, "midline" is sagittal / front-back and "cross strap" is coronal / left-right.
    As I explained, the problem is with midline electrodes - they aren't snug well since the midline doesn't close as the other straps.
    I use a coronal strap that goes all the way around the chin and so can be tightened.
  • wjcroftwjcroft Mount Shasta, CA
    Chin strap is a great idea and is commonly used. I don't generally need it as my left-right straps put more downward tension on top of the front-back strap. I generally work with site pairs like F3 F4, C3 C4, P3 P4, T3 T4. So as many straps as needed for the montage.

    What sensors and saline are you using? Once the Ag-AgCl button sensor with saline soaked chamois contacts the skin, very little downward pressure is needed. The current is flowing through the saline/skin interface which is not very pressure dependent. Be sure that you have parted the hair at the site so that the chamois can contact the scalp more easily. The saline can go through a small amount of hair, but not layers of it.

    One other adaptation you can use, is to incorporate an elastic velcro for the hatband. Velcro does make this material and the Velcro One-Wrap straps can stick to it. The elastic then allows more force to be applied. Athletic sweat bands can also be used. I use the elastic setup for tDCS when I'm applying Amrex sponge holders. These cover larger 2x2 inch areas so do need more downward pressure.
  • Thank you for sharing this, William! I'm new here and I really appreciate your posts.
Sign In or Register to comment.